Best butt plug tails, ranked by Coyscore

Seven tail plugs, ranked by aggregated review score. All of them add a bit of theatre to anal play — the question is which one stays comfortable long enough for you to enjoy it. We've scored them on beginner-friendliness, material, ease of use and what reviewers actually report, then sorted by overall Coyscore.

We ranked these seven tail plugs by Coyscore, which aggregates 921 reviews across the range and weighs beginner-friendliness, body safety, ease of use, performance, satisfaction and value. Every product here has a score; every score reflects real buyer feedback, not editorial opinion. The counts are on each card, the method is on the methodology page.

The Neon Bunny Plug Tail 5 Inch — Blue leads at Coyscore 86, with 58 reviews averaging 4.6 stars. Reviewers like the size and the fact that it stays put without asking too much of you — a good first tail if you're new to plugs generally.

The Bunny Plug Tail 6.7 Inch — Purple scores 81 across 215 reviews (4.3 stars). It's longer than the Neon, and reviewers are consistent: comfortable for extended wear, though the tail itself divides opinion — some love the fluff, others find it sheds.

Its sibling, the Bunny Plug Tail 6.7 Inch — Pink, scores identically — same plug, same 215-review aggregate, same 4.3 stars. If you're choosing between the two, it's purely aesthetic.

The No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch sits at 74 across 69 reviews (3.7 stars). Reviewers report it's firmer than the bunny plugs and less forgiving if you're still working up to this length. It stays in well once it's there, but getting there is the work.

The Tailz Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug scores 73 with 132 reviews at 4.4 stars. It's well-liked for the quality of the tail and the plug's taper, though a few reviewers note the neck could be thinner — it doesn't always settle as securely as they'd like.

The Dog Tail Butt Plug from Master Series scores 70 across 198 reviews (4.1 stars). The tail is the draw here — longer and more dramatic than the bunny options — but the plug itself is basic, and reviewers who wanted more from the plug than just a tail anchor were disappointed.

We excluded one product because we already had a pick from that brand. One tail plug per maker keeps the list useful rather than repetitive.

Is this butt plug body-safe? Most of the plugs here are silicone, which is non-porous and cleans properly with soap and hot water. One is listed as rubber — we can't verify its porosity from the spec, so treat it as porous unless the supplier states otherwise, which means a fresh condom each time and no sharing.

Is this butt plug good for beginners? The 5-inch Neon scores highest on beginner-friendliness and reviewers back that up. The 6.7-inch plugs are longer and ask more of you — fine if you've used a plug before, probably too much if you haven't. Silicone is softer than glass or steel, which helps, but length still matters.

Will this butt plug stay in during use? The ones with a defined neck and a flared base stay put best. Reviewers mention the Tailz Onyx could use a thinner neck, and the Dog Tail's plug is basic enough that it can shift if you're moving around. The bunny plugs generally stay where you put them.

Is this product suitable for beginners? The 5-inch Neon is. The 6.7-inch plugs are not, unless you're already comfortable with something close to that length. Reviewers who tried the longer ones as a first plug mostly regretted it.

What is the tail made of and is it detachable? The tails are faux fur or similar synthetic, and most are sewn or glued to the plug base — not detachable. That makes cleaning fiddly. Wash the plug as usual, spot-clean the tail, and let it dry completely before you store it.

Is the material body-safe? Silicone is body-safe. Rubber is not a precise term and often means a porous material that cannot be sterilised — if the spec just says "rubber", assume it's porous and use a condom. If it says "100% silicone", you're fine.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.