Aeystheter Collection — every product, scored

Aeystheter Collection makes two anal toys that sit at opposite ends of the beginner-to-experienced spectrum, and both score well. One is a plug that reviewers consistently call comfortable and easy to live with. The other is a vibrating prostate toy that asks more of you but delivers if you know what you want. Average Coyscore across the range is 82, which puts them comfortably above most of what we track.

They make a butt plug and a prostate vibrator. The SASSY Anal Plug is the higher-scoring of the two — 190 reviews, Coyscore 85, and the kind of product that gets recommended to friends. The Andrew Anal Stimulating Vibrator has more than twice the review count at 409, scores 79, and divides opinion in ways that tell you exactly who it suits. Between them they cover the two most common reasons someone goes looking for an anal toy: something to wear comfortably, and something to target the prostate.

One of the two products is silicone, the other is PVC. That means half the range is non-porous and will last as long as you look after it, and half requires a condom each time and cannot be sterilised. At brand level that is neither remarkable nor poor — it simply means you check the spec before you buy. The silicone product is the plug; the PVC one is the vibrator. Both materials are common in their respective categories, and both are disclosed in the supplier spec.

The SASSY Anal Plug is their standout — Coyscore 85, Coy Recommended, and the product reviewers return to when they want something that just works. It is body-safe silicone, comfortable enough to wear for a while, and consistently praised for being exactly what it looks like. The Andrew Anal Stimulating Vibrator scores 79 and earns a Worth a Look grade. It has a much larger review base and a more divided reception, which makes sense for a prostate toy — they suit some people brilliantly and frustrate others. If you know you want targeted vibration and you are past the beginner stage, it is worth considering. If you are still working out what you like, start with the plug.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.