No11 Butt Plug 6 Inch vs Dog Tail Butt Plug

Two tail plugs at opposite ends of the weight spectrum. The No11 is a 6-inch TPR plug that sits heavier in the hand at 381 grams — you will know it is there. The Dog Tail is longer at 7.5 inches, lighter at 244 grams, and backed by nearly three times the review count. They share a category and a purpose, but the experience of wearing them is not the same.

The Dog Tail has been reviewed 198 times across retailers, averaging 4.1 stars. The No11 has 69 reviews at 3.7 stars. Both counts are high enough to trust, and the Dog Tail's higher average suggests more consistent satisfaction — though the No11's score is still respectable for a plug of this size.

The No11 is shorter at 6 inches insertable, but heavier at 381 grams — more than half again the Dog Tail's 244 grams. That extra weight makes it more present during wear, which some people want and others find tiring. The Dog Tail's 7.5 inches gives you more length without the heft, so it sits differently and asks less of your body over time.

We do not have diameter, taper or base measurements for either, so we cannot compare how they open you up or how securely they anchor. That matters more than length for most people, and the absence is frustrating.

Both are tail plugs, both sit in the same subcategory, and both are aimed at the same kind of play. Beyond that, the spec gaps make it hard to say where else they align. We know what they weigh and how long they are, but not how wide, how they taper, or what the base looks like — and those are the things that decide whether a plug works for you.

If you want to feel the plug constantly and you like a bit of heft, the No11's 381 grams will give you that. It is shorter, so it suits people who find 7.5 inches too much but still want presence. The Dog Tail is for longer wear or movement — lighter, longer, and with a review count that suggests it holds up across a wider range of bodies. If you are new to tails, the Dog Tail's higher score and larger sample size make it the safer bet.

Neither has confirmed diameter or taper data, so if girth is your concern, you will need to ask the retailer before you buy.

Is the No11 body-safe? It is listed as TPR, which is porous and cannot be sterilised. Keep it to one person, use a fresh condom each time, and replace it when it starts to degrade. Silicone would be a better long-term choice at this price point.

Is 6 inches suitable for beginners? Length-wise, probably not — most people start shorter. But if you have worked up to this size already and want the tail aesthetic, it is not outlandish. The lack of diameter data makes it hard to say for certain.

Will the Dog Tail stay in during movement? We do not have base or neck measurements, so we cannot confirm. A flared or T-shaped base and a defined neck are what keep a plug secure — ask the retailer for those specs if you plan to wear it while moving around.

What is the Dog Tail's material? The data lists it as "Rubber Rubber", which is not a standard material designation and tells us nothing about porosity or care. We cannot confirm body-safety without a proper spec, so treat it as porous unless the supplier states otherwise.

The Dog Tail has the review count, the higher score, and the lighter build that makes it easier to wear for longer. The No11 has the heft and the shorter length, which will suit people who want that specific combination — but TPR at this price is hard to recommend when silicone alternatives exist. If you are deciding between these two, the Dog Tail is the safer choice unless you specifically want a heavier, shorter plug. Either way, ask the retailer for diameter and base specs before you buy — those matter more than length, and we do not have them for either.

Both are stocked at multiple retailers. Compare prices, check current availability, and confirm the material spec before you order — especially for the Dog Tail, where the listing is unclear.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.