Tailz Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug vs Dog Tail Butt Plug

Two tail plugs from the same range, separated by size and weight. The Bunny Tail sits at 5 inches insertable and 120 grams — a manageable starting point. The Dog Tail stretches to 7.5 inches and 244 grams, which is twice the weight and half again the length. Both have drawn solid review counts, but the Bunny Tail edges ahead on average rating. If you are new to tail play or plugs in general, the Bunny is the obvious pick. If you want presence and heft, the Dog delivers it.

The Bunny Tail has 132 reviews averaging 4.4 stars. The Dog Tail has 198 reviews averaging 4.1 stars. Both counts are high enough to trust, and both products hold their ratings across multiple retailers. The Bunny's slightly higher score reflects consistent praise for fit and comfort, while the Dog's larger review count shows it is the more popular choice — though reviewers are a fraction less enthusiastic once they have used it.

The Dog Tail is 7.5 inches insertable against the Bunny's 5 inches — a significant jump that changes how the plug sits and how much you feel it. The Dog also weighs 244 grams, more than double the Bunny's 120 grams. That extra weight is part of the appeal for some users, but it also means the plug is harder to forget about, which is not always what you want. If you are choosing between them, the size and weight are the only statable differences — everything else is either the same or not specified for both.

We cannot confirm where these two are identical, because the specs do not state material, diameter, base design or taper for either product. What we do know — insertable length and weight — is covered above. If other details matter to you, check the retailer listing before you buy.

If you are new to plugs or tail play, or if you want something you can wear comfortably for a while, the Bunny Tail is the better fit. Reviewers consistently call it beginner-friendly, and the 5-inch length with lighter weight makes it easier to get used to. If you have experience with plugs and want something with more presence — something you will always know is there — the Dog Tail's extra length and heft will suit you. It is not a step up; it is a different experience. Choose based on what you want to feel, not what sounds more advanced.

Is the Bunny Tail suitable for beginners? Yes — several reviewers recommend it for beginners, noting it is a "perfect size for a beginner to use and fits well". The 5-inch insertable length and lighter weight make it easier to start with than the Dog Tail.

What is the tail made of and is it detachable? Both products list "Rubber Rubber" as the material, which tells us nothing useful. Some tail plugs in this category have detachable tails for easier cleaning, but we cannot confirm whether these two do. Check the retailer listing if that matters to you.

Is the material body-safe? We do not know. "Rubber Rubber" is not a material specification we can interpret, and neither product lists whether it is porous or non-porous. Silicone and stainless steel are the safest bets for plugs; if the spec does not confirm either, assume you will need to use a condom each time and replace the plug regularly.

The Bunny Tail scores 73 and the Dog Tail scores 70 — both are solid, both are popular, and the difference comes down to what you want from the experience. The Bunny is lighter, shorter, and easier to live with, which is why beginners prefer it and why it holds the higher rating. The Dog is heavier, longer, and more present, which some users love and others find too much. Neither is better; they are just aimed at different moments. If you are unsure, start with the Bunny. If you know you want weight and length, the Dog will give you that.

Both the Tailz Onyx Bunny Tail Anal Plug and the Dog Tail Butt Plug are stocked by multiple retailers, including Lovehoney and other major online stores. Prices vary, so check a few before you buy. If you are in New Zealand, Coy — the retailer behind this site — stocks both.

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.