Classic Butt Plug Smooth Medium review

A smooth, tapered plug that reviewers consistently describe as the right size for people who have tried a small one and want to go further. Weighty enough that you know it's there, soft enough that it goes in without drama, and priced low enough that you can afford to find out whether you like the feeling.

Reviewers describe a plug that feels substantial without asking too much of you. The weight is what people mention first — not heavy in a way that makes it uncomfortable, but present enough that you're aware of it when you move. One user put it plainly: "Once it's in it's in and can feel it whenever you move because of the weight."

The taper does what it's meant to. People report that it goes in steadily if you take your time and use enough lube, and that the flared base keeps it exactly where you put it. One beginner noted they managed to get it 80% in on a first attempt, slow and steady. Another, who'd been using a smaller plug, said this one delivered the stretch they were looking for.

The material is soft PVC, which divides opinion slightly. Most people like that it has some give — it makes insertion easier and the plug more forgiving if you're still working out what you're doing. A smaller number find it too soft, one calling it "sort of flimsy" and wishing for something firmer. The softness does mean you can warm it under the tap or cool it in the fridge, which several reviewers mention enjoying.

Where it works best is as a step up from a beginner plug, or as preparation before anal sex. One reviewer uses it for half an hour before a session, saying the width stretches them out and the depth gives them some of the feeling they're after. Another calls it their favourite for exactly that reason — slightly larger than average, enough to make a difference.

It's a plug for people who know they like the sensation and want more of it, or for beginners who are ready to try something beyond the very smallest sizes.

This suits people who have tried a small plug and want to go further, or anyone who knows they prefer a bit of size and weight. If you're using it as warm-up before anal sex, reviewers say it does that job well — the width and depth are enough to make a difference.

If you're brand new to anal play and haven't tried anything yet, start smaller. This one is manageable for beginners who take it slowly, but it's not the gentlest introduction. And if you prefer a firmer plug that holds its shape more decisively, this one might feel too soft — a few reviewers wished for something less yielding.

The material means you'll need to replace it sooner than you would a silicone plug, and it can't be boiled. If you want something that lasts for years and can be sterilised, look at the non-porous options in the butt plug ranking.

PVC is a porous material, which means it cannot be sterilised. Keep it to one person, give it a fresh condom each time if you're sharing, and replace it when the surface starts to feel tacky or rough — usually within a year or two of regular use.

Wash it with warm water and mild soap after each use, rinse thoroughly, and let it dry completely before you put it away. It doesn't come with a storage bag, so keep it somewhere it won't pick up dust or press against other toys. Use water-based lube only — silicone-based and oil-based lubes can degrade PVC.

You can warm it under the tap or cool it in the fridge, which several reviewers enjoy. Don't boil it and don't put it in the dishwasher.

This sits in the middle of the butt plug range — not a beginner's first plug, not an advanced size, but the step most people take when they're ready for more. It appears in the best butt plugs ranking, where you can see how it compares on size, material and price.

If you're wondering whether this is the right size for you, or whether you should be looking at silicone instead, that page answers both.

Is this butt plug suitable for beginners? Yes, though it's better as a second plug than a first one. Reviewers who were new to anal play managed it with patience and plenty of lube — one said they got it 80% in on a first attempt, slow and steady. If you haven't tried anything yet, start smaller.

Can this butt plug be used for stretching? Yes, and that's one of the things reviewers mention most. One user said it's their favourite for exactly that reason: "It's great as preparation for anal sex as the circumference is wide enough to stretch you out and the depth provides some deeper feel, so wearing one of these for half an hour before a play session works really well."

What is the material of the butt plug? Phthalate-free PVC. It's soft, has some give, and can be warmed or cooled. It's also porous, which means it can't be sterilised — see the care section for what that means in practice.

A solid mid-range plug that does what most people want from one: enough size to feel like a step up, enough weight to stay put, and a taper that makes insertion straightforward if you take your time. The material is soft and forgiving, which beginners appreciate and a few more experienced users find too yielding.

It's porous, so it won't last as long as a silicone plug and you'll need to replace it sooner. But at this price, that's a reasonable trade-off — especially if you're still working out what size and shape you prefer. Reviewers who wanted a plug for stretching or warm-up say it does the job well.

Available now for $19.95. The geo-router will show you where to get it depending on where you are.

This review draws on 250 public reviews across 6 retailers, averaging 4.6 stars. The Coyscore is 76 — the method is on the methodology page, and the evidence count is here because we want you to know what sits behind the claims. Confidence is high: enough reviews, across enough sources, to trust the pattern.

Insertable length: 5.3 inches (derived from supplier data)
Material: PVC (supplier spec)
Non-porous: No (derived from supplier data)
Weight: 0.13 kg (supplier data)
Maximum diameter: Not stated by the supplier
Flared base: Not stated by the supplier — safety-critical, so we don't infer it from the subcategory
Taper: Not stated by the supplier

The Snug Report is published by the team behind Coy, a New Zealand retailer that stocks many of the products reviewed here. We say so on every page. Our scores come from aggregated public reviews, not from us — the method is on the methodology page and the evidence count is on every review.